Four Warning Signs of a Hardened Heart
A hardened heart is a deadly condition that often goes silent.
Patrick Oben
The human heart is God's mysterious connection between the spirit realm and the natural realm. Whether God or Satan has access to a person's earthly life, or to a community, can be traced back to the state of the people's hearts.
When the heart is open to God, Scripture often calls it a heart of flesh. But when it resists and opposes Him, it is called a hardened heart.
A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you: and I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh.
— Ezekiel 36:26, KJV
A hardened heart is a deadly condition that often goes silent, because it is not obvious from the outside.
And no, a hardened heart is not for unbelievers only. In fact, this newsletter is not about unbelievers. It is about you and me, God's children. I have experienced a hardened heart, and I continue to experience it when I let my heart drift away. Yes, I still do. I have to always be on guard, just like every one of you. [Proverbs 4:23]
Today, let me share four quick signs of a hardened heart. But first, a quick note on what the heart is and what a hardened heart is.

What Is the Human Heart?
This is one of the most confusing aspects of biblical teaching about our own nature. The terms heart, soul, spirit, inner man, hidden man, and so on can get very confusing. [Ephesians 3:16; 1 Peter 3:4] I have written many articles about the difference between the soul and the spirit, and about what the human heart really is.
I cannot get into the details here, but here is a quick summary.
Think of a human being as made up of two parts:
- An outward part that we can all see: your body, your actions, your words, and so on.
- An inner part that we cannot see: your thoughts, your feelings, your decisions, and so on.
That inner part of you is what the Bible often calls the heart.
Here is the first warning: do not do the Pentecostal thing of forcing the heart to mean the human spirit. There are a few verses in the Bible where Scripture uses the term heart for the spirit. But overwhelmingly, it is used for the inner part of man. Operationally, the heart works through our thoughts, feelings, and will. Constitutionally, it is made up of the spirit and the soul.
So the heart is the spirit and the soul, the inner part of man, which together function as our thoughts, feelings, and will.

Right now, as you read this, you are thinking in your heart. That is your heart. [Proverbs 23:7] You do not need to be in some super-spiritual state to contact your heart. Both Christians and unbelievers have hearts.
So What Is a Hardened Heart?
Here is what happened between Jesus and the Jews of His day:
And when he had looked round about on them with anger, being grieved for the hardness of their hearts...
— Mark 3:5, KJV
Jesus was grieved by the hardness of the people's hearts. Let me explain this in a very simple way.
First, notice that the word hard is figurative here. It pictures the heart as an object. In this context, hard means firm and unyielding, something that resists pressure. Think of a piece of stone. If you press it, nothing changes. Now compare that to butter. Very little pressure on butter makes it move and changes its shape. But the same pressure on a stone makes no difference.
Here is the second important part. Remember what I said above: the heart is your feelings, thoughts, and will. Let me use the will as an example, because it is the easiest to explain.
Imagine I want to do something that God's Word clearly tells me not to do. I want to do it. That is my will (the heart). God's Word tells me not to do it.
For example, last week we talked about lust. Imagine I want to go after a woman who is not my wife, and I know clearly that the Word says no. [Matthew 5:28] My will (my heart) is to do it. God's Word says no. For me to stop and not do it, I must be willing to let God's Word, the external restraint or pressure, change my will.
A soft heart is yielding and malleable. It can change and go in the direction God wants. Imagine I remember God's Word, change my mind (my will), and decide not to do it because God said so. That is a soft heart, which the Bible calls a heart of flesh. God can change it by His Word.
Now think of a hardened heart. I want to do it. God's Word says no. But like a rock, my heart is unyielding. I do what I want, no matter what. Nothing external changes my decision. That is a hardened heart. God cannot control it. Like a rock, no matter how hard you press it, it stays fixed.

Brethren, that is what a hardened heart is, from one simple example. The same is true of every component of the heart.
For example, imagine I am very anxious (my feelings, the heart). God's Word says, be anxious for nothing.
Be careful for nothing; but in every thing by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known unto God.
— Philippians 4:6, KJV
But my emotions are so fixed on the anxiety that they cannot change to obey God's Word. That is a hardened heart. It cannot be molded to do what God wants.
You can now see that a hardened heart can express itself in different ways, depending on which part of the heart is hardened.
Sign 1: Unbelief
The Bible says that with the heart man believes, and our eternal destiny hangs on what we believe.
For with the heart man believeth unto righteousness; and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation.
— Romans 10:10, KJV
The most deadly sign of a hardened heart is not believing God's Word. The world does not believe in Jesus, and that is the most costly eternal mistake a human being can ever make. But as Christians, we know that we also continue to struggle with believing God's Word. I just gave you an example above. God says be anxious for nothing. But how many of you continue to be anxious too?
We saw above that Jesus was grieved for the hardness of their hearts. [Mark 3:5] And in Hebrews, Scripture tells us that if we hear His voice, we should not harden our hearts.
While it is said, To day if ye will hear his voice, harden not your hearts, as in the provocation.
— Hebrews 3:15, KJV
Notice that it says we harden our hearts. It is under our control, not something outside of our control.
So the first and most deadly sign of a hardened heart in our daily walk with the Lord is hearing His Word and hardening our hearts by not believing it.
This week, I found myself crying out to God, like the man in the Gospel: Lord, I believe; help thou mine unbelief.
And straightway the father of the child cried out, and said with tears, Lord, I believe; help thou mine unbelief.
— Mark 9:24, KJV

May the Lord help you too. Take hold of His Word, and believe it in the things that are causing you fear, anxiety, worry, and so on.
Sign 2: Lack of Understanding
A heart that does not understand God's Word is a hardened heart. It is a mind that cannot grasp spiritual truth. Scripture calls it spiritually dull. [Matthew 13:15] As Paul states:
Having the understanding darkened, being alienated from the life of God through the ignorance that is in them, because of the blindness of their heart.
— Ephesians 4:18, KJV
As I have shared before, one other key warning sign I notice in my own heart is when my spiritual understanding starts going down. It taught me that spiritual understanding is not merely an intellectual activity. It is a Spirit-breathed thing in us. It is not from us. [Job 32:8; 1 Corinthians 2:14]
When our hearts become hardened, spiritual truth becomes difficult to comprehend and grasp.
Sign 3: Disobedience
When we are disobedient, we do what we want to do, irrespective of what God says. In Hebrews chapters 3 and 4, God intentionally puts unbelief and disobedience close together, because they often go together.
Take heed, brethren, lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief, in departing from the living God. But exhort one another daily, while it is called To day; lest any of you be hardened through the deceitfulness of sin.
— Hebrews 3:12–13, KJV
Here is one of the most deadly spiritual conditions we can find ourselves in as Christians: knowing God's Word and willfully disobeying it, again and again. That is a gross sign that our hearts are callous and hardened. When we lose the fear of God, we disobey His commands, looking Him in the face. [Psalm 36:1]
In today's age, if I, a minister, have a girlfriend, live in sin on Saturday night, and then come to preach and prophesy on Sunday, it is a sign that my heart is callous before God.
Well, remember that David did the same. He killed Uriah and took his wife. But when God's Word confronted him, he wept in repentance. [2 Samuel 11–12; Psalm 51]
Did you notice that? David sinned, but that in itself was not the defining thing. When God's rebuke came to him, he repented. That is the sign of a contrite, broken heart, not a callous, hardened one.
The sacrifices of God are a broken spirit: a broken and a contrite heart, O God, thou wilt not despise.
— Psalm 51:17, KJV
Today, when we sin, hear God's rebuke, and continue to sin, not only are our hearts hardened, but we have completely lost the fear of God altogether, whether we are prophets, apostles, or anyone else.
Brethren, you might read this and think that it happens to other people. You might be thinking of that preacher or that Christian, but not seeing yourself.
That attitude itself should make you very concerned. It is a judgmental spirit, blind to our own sins and weaknesses and quick to see the errors of others. [Matthew 7:3–5]
None of us reading this newsletter is immune to this condition if we do not watch. As long as we are in this body of flesh, sin is around the corner. If we do not watch, we will be carried away. [Matthew 26:41; 1 Corinthians 10:12]
As I mentioned above, I watch my own life as much as you do. And yes, many times I also go off in some areas, and I depend on Him completely.
Let me share one of my spiritual secrets with you. I have learned not to depend on my own strength, or even my own ability, to please God. It is one of the best spiritual lessons I have learned. I became free the day I learned that I am not under any pressure to be perfect before God. I am open to Him. He is my Father and my Helper. When I get off track, I do not run from Him. I go to Him in full assurance. [Hebrews 4:16; Hebrews 10:22]

I pray the Lord helps you too. If any of you reading this are running away from God, feeling that your failures have made you no longer worthy, I can tell you that your Christian environment and church upbringing are responsible for that, not your Father. He wants you back. Like David, make a U-turn and return.
Sign 4: Insensitivity
Let me describe this with an example. It will be easier than trying to explain it.
Imagine Jesus came to your home as a visitor. You took Him in, asked Him what He wanted, talked with Him, and then told Him goodbye. Then He left. And all the while, you did not know it was Jesus.

That is called spiritual insensitivity. It means we fail to discern God. This example is physical, but it applies in every case. It is failing to recognize God's voice, God's leading, and what He wants.
In other words, God moves and you have no idea. He speaks and you do not hear. Or you hear Him speak, and you are confused and not even sure whether it is God, yourself, or Satan. That is called a lack of discernment. [John 10:27]
When our hearts are hardened, we fail to recognize our Father in the many ways He comes to us.
One of the worst cases of spiritual blindness, or lack of discernment, in Scripture is the nation of Israel. Yahweh, their own God, came to them, and they did not recognize Him. [John 1:10–11] For example, the hardness of heart seen in Israel closed their minds to recognizing Jesus as their Messiah.
For I would not, brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits; that blindness in part is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the Gentiles be come in.
— Romans 11:25, KJV
And before you blame Israel, think about yourself today. We have the Holy Spirit, yet we fail to recognize Him as much as Israel did. That is why we need Him. We need His grace and mercy just as much.
Which Signs Are an Issue for You Now?
I have briefly discussed four signs of a hardened heart:
- Unbelief
- Lack of understanding
- Disobedience
- Insensitivity
If we were all together in one place, I would have led us to pray and cry out to God together, asking Him to help our stubborn, or unbelieving, or dull, or insensitive hearts.
As I mentioned above, this week, as I wrestled to bring my heart to believe the Word, I got to a point where I just had to pray like that man: Lord, I believe; help thou mine unbelief. [Mark 9:24]
And here is one thing I want many of you to catch. Please believe and trust me, as a teacher of the Word and a Christian like you: many of us do not really know our Father's heart. Religion and Christianity have damaged our understanding of God. Many of us have a distorted picture of God.
For example, some of you will read this newsletter and, instead of drawing close to God, the religious spirit will make you anxious, wondering whether God is angry with you. I pray, and pray again, that Satan does not use God's Word to destroy your life with religion.
Our Father is good, a good, good Father. I repeat: God is not demanding perfection from you. He wants a soft heart. He knows you will sin and even make mistakes. When you sin, He wants you to have a contrite heart like David, and to turn to Him, not to try to justify yourself or harden your heart. [Psalm 51:17]
Whether you are dealing with disobedience right now and running away from God, or struggling to believe His Word on something, here is God's Word for you:
My son, give me thine heart, and let thine eyes observe my ways.
— Proverbs 23:26, KJV
Just yield to Me. Give Me your heart, and trust Me.
I pray for you all. Which of these signs of a hardened heart are you struggling with now? You can reply to this email, or leave a comment if it is a general thing.
Keep this conversation going.
Browse the Weekly archive ↗Continue in the Word
All teachings ↗A letter for your life in the Word
Deshen Weekly
Receive one weekly teaching from Deshen Ministries. Confirm your email to join; unsubscribe anytime.

Join the conversation
Comments
No comments have been published yet.
Leave a comment
Share a thoughtful response. Comments are reviewed before they appear publicly.


